Engagement and growth metrics have always been the go-to tools for marketing teams worldwide. But somewhere along the way, certain metrics started to get a bad reputation as “vanity metrics” — the kind that makes you look good on paper but don’t always correlate to real business outcomes. 

In this article, let’s explore why these metrics earned their “vanity” label, why they still have value, and how content marketers can use them to fuel business or career goals.

What the hell are vanity metrics in content marketing, anyway?

Vanity metrics are those surface-level numbers that focus on quantity over quality. Think about social media followers, likes, website traffic—those feel-good figures that, at first glance, don’t seem to say much about how well your marketing is working.

Here’s a list of the usual “vanity metrics” suspects:

• Impressions, reach
• Likes, shares, comments
• Follower growth
• Open rates, click-through-rates�
• Traffic, page views, time on site, bounce rates, etc.

But let me cut straight to the point: I don’t buy into the notion that these are *just* vanity metrics. Why? Because any metric can be “vain” if you only look at it in isolation. When used right, these metrics can provide valuable insights into the bigger picture of your marketing strategy.

Why does vanity get a bad rap?

The term “vanity” often refers to something empty or self-centered, and in marketing, it’s usually used to describe metrics that don’t seem to offer actionable insights. The assumption is that unless a metric directly influences a business decision or behavior, it’s not worth tracking.

But here’s the issue: thinking in absolutes. Not everything is black and white. Metrics — even so-called actionable ones — need context to be useful.

To understand the real value of metrics, let’s talk about leading and lagging indicators

• Lagging indicators show you what happened after the fact. For example, if you’re trying to improve the quality of a product, you might want the number of issues reported 30 days after launch to be below a certain number. The downside? You have to wait until after the fact to get the data.
• Leading indicators, on the other hand, give you real-time insights into whether you’re on the right path. For instance, tracking the number of bugs discovered and fixed per day can tell you if your team is moving towards higher efficiency. You can spot issues on a rolling basis, and optimize processes for a potentially better outcome at the end of the observation period.

But here’s the thing — leading indicators can be manipulated. Someone could simply run more tests just to make the numbers look good, without improving product quality. So does that make the number of tests a vanity metric? Not necessarily.

Another example:

• Lagging indicator, e.g: Monthly Recurring Revenue (MRR) is a predicatble, actionable and recurring revenue generated from paying users each month. It showcases the financial stability and growth potential of marketing efforts (in combination with product and engineering) in a SaaS business.

• Leading indicator, e.g: free trial sign-ups: The number of converted users signing up for a free trial of your product can potentially predict future revenue. An increase in free trial sign-ups might suggest a growing pool of potential paying customers. Using historical data (lagging indicator), a marketer can calculate potential conversions to predict future paying customers (while optimizing efforts in realtime across all marketing touchpoints).

Different metrics for different people

Metrics that seem like fluff to one person can be gold to someone else. A C-suite executive might care most about sales and ROI, while a marketing lead could be focused on metrics like brand awareness or share of voice. 

Also, different metrics vary in importance across different industries. Blog page views are extremely important in media and news publications but might be secondary in, say, B2B fintech.

So, should we throw out “vanity” metrics just because they don’t tell the whole story? Not at all. In fact, they can provide helpful clues when interpreted correctly.

Actionable insights vs. vanity metrics

Vanity metrics might not give you the clear next steps, but that doesn’t mean they don’t have value. It’s all about knowing which metrics align with your goals. The key is to focus on quality over quantity and combine different data points to see the full picture.

For example, page views might seem like a basic metric, but when you pair them with other data — like which channel is driving conversions — you start to see more actionable insights. Maybe you find that organic search traffic leads to more conversions than email campaigns, even though both bring in a lot of views.

Avoiding the vanity trap

The real danger with vanity metrics is they can be gamed. You can drive tons of meaningless traffic to a site, knowing it won’t lead to real growth, but still make your numbers look impressive. But as long as you’re using these metrics honestly and in context, they can serve as valuable leading indicators.

Conversion touchpoints are where the magic happens

Every piece of content you produce can offer opportunities for your audience to engage – whether it’s clicking a link or interacting with a product. Tracking these interactions is essential to optimizing their experience. 

Understanding where people are clicking, why they’re doing so, and what actions they’re completing helps you fine-tune your content strategy. This is where even seemingly superficial metrics can start to reveal deeper insights.

Vanity metrics and A/B testing

Vanity metrics can play a crucial role in A/B testing. Imagine you’re running a Facebook ad and want to test which image resonates more with your audience. You need metrics like impressions and click-through rates (CTR) to measure performance. These numbers help you decide whether a photo of a person holding a phone drives more engagement than one of just hands holding the same phone.

By looking at these metrics in the short term, you can optimize your campaigns without waiting for final conversion numbers. In this way, vanity metrics serve as good leading indicators that tell you if you’re on the right track.

So, are vanity metrics good or bad in content marketing?

Like most things in marketing, the answer is: it depends. Vanity metrics aren’t inherently bad; they just need context. When you combine them with other meaningful metrics, they can help you uncover new insights about your business or brand story.

The bottom line is this: don’t write off any metric as “vanity” without first understanding its potential value. Think of every metric as part of a broader narrative. With the right approach, even the most surface-level data can help you optimize your marketing efforts and move closer to your content marketing goals.

Takeaways

• Define your goals: Before you measure anything, know what you want to achieve.
• Tailor your metrics: What matters to one team might not matter to another, so make sure you’re tracking what’s relevant to your specific campaign goals.
• Don’t over-measure: Be selective about what you track and always ask yourself, “Does this metric actually help me improve?”
• Communicate value: Help stakeholders understand how your metrics contribute to the bigger picture, even if some of them seem trivial.

Vanity metrics aren’t useless — they’re just part of a bigger toolkit. Use them wisely, and they can guide you toward deeper, actionable insights.

Vanity metrics can be incredibly useful as parts of your marketing engine, rather than being the driving force. So instead of putting certain metrics into a “vanity metrics” bucket, look at every metric as an opportunity to unlock more of your company’s story that you have yet to tell. 

Remember, in content marketing, data is our biggest asset and should always be our best friend. 

Thanks for reading to the end. If you found this article useful, please follow me on LinkedIn and consider sharing this article with your network.